Petey Wheaty's - New City

Petey Wheaty's is an American (Traditional) restaurant in NEW CITY, NY. Order takeout online for pickup or delivery.

145 SOUTH MAIN STREET
NEW CITY, NY 10956

Phone: +18457085030

Price range: $11-$20

Cuisine: American (Traditional)

Hours

  • Sunday: 12:30–21:00
  • Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday: 11:30–22:00
  • Friday: 11:30–23:00
  • Saturday: 12:00–23:00

Petey Wheaty's - New City Menu

From the Fryer

  • Chicken Tender — $10.49
    Breaded chicken strips, juicy and succulent on the inside and crispy on the outside.
  • Empanadas — $4.99
    Mouth-watering meat and plant-based Argentinean-style empanadas.
  • Mozzarella Sticks — $8.49
    Battered Mozzarella sticks, ooey, gooey and delicious.
  • Pepperoni Pizza Rolls — $8.49
    Mouth-watering wonton wrappers filled with pepperoni, sauce and cheese, deep-fried to perfection.
  • Wings — $9.49
    Hot, fried, tender wings served with your choice of sauce.
  • Clam Strips — $10.49
    Breaded clam strips, fried and served with tartar sauce.

Salads

  • Kale Edamame Chickpea Salad — $8.00
    Vegan, gluten-free. Fresh kale, edamame, and chickpea dressed in a light vinaigrette and served over baby spinach.
  • Mediterranean Couscous Salad — $8.00
    Vegan. Tender and plump Israeli couscous, walnuts and cranberries dressed in a light vinaigrette served over baby spinach.

Sides

  • French Fries — $3.99
  • Southern HWY 40 Fries — $4.99
  • Coleslaw — $4.99
  • Baked Beans — $3.99
  • Macaroni & Cheese — $4.99
  • Mashed Potatoes — $4.99
  • Sweet Potato Mashed — $5.99
  • Chicken Gravy — $3.99
  • Southern Fried Chicken Tenders — $13.99
    With fries.
  • Clam Strips from The Sea. — $12.50
    With fries.
  • Chucky Cheeseburger — $14.50
    With fries and pickles.
  • Empanada — $4.99
    Beef, chicken, cheese, cheeseburger, pizza and more!
  • Cheese Fries — $4.99
  • Hot Dog — $5.99
    1/4 lb. Hebrew national.
  • Breaded Chicken Sandwich — $8.99
    On a sesame seed roll.
  • Tortilla Chips — $4.99
    Comes with either salsa, sour cream or queso.
  • Tortilla Nachos — $4.99
    Comes with either salsa, sour cream or queso.
  • Guacamole — $3.50
  • Reynaldo’s Coconut Rice Pudding — $2.99

Burgers & Grill

  • Beef Quesadilla — $7.39
  • Chicken Quesadilla — $7.39
  • Hot Open Roast Beef Sandwich — $15.45
  • Hot Open Turkey Sandwich — $12.45
  • Pat La Frieda Hamburger — $9.00
    A classic, grilled and juicy 6oz burger served on a Martin's potato roll with pickles (huck, short ribs and brisket mix).
  • Quesadilla Deluxe — $11.19
    Quesadilla of choiced served with side of fries.
  • Chucky Cheeseburger — $10.00
    As if the classic burger couldn't get any better, this one has cheese. Burgers are 6 oz with a mix of chuck, short ribs and brisket pasture raised and made locally.
  • Binster Burger — $9.49
    Dairy-free, gluten-free bread available. A delicious veggie burger for all of our veggie friends.

Hot Dogs

  • Classic Dog — $7.49
    4 oz 100% beef, natural casing hot dog served on a potato bun.
  • Dog 'n Onion Sauce Dog — $8.49
    Our classic 4 oz Hebrew National, 100% beef and natural casing hot dog. This juicy and flavorful dog is served up on Martin's potato roll with an onion and tomato base sauce.
  • Chili Dog — $8.49
    Our classic dog served with a delicious savory chili.

Milti's Sandwiches

  • Breaded Chicken Sandwich — $8.49
    4 variations. Juicy breaded chicken breast served on Martin's potato roll.

Brownies & Crumb Cakes

  • Brownie — $5.49
    Made with Ghirardelli chocolate and M&M's.
  • Crumb Cakes — $3.75
    Per slice. Most vanilla crumb cake with a buttery streusel topping.

Ice Cream

  • Hard-Cup — $5.59
    Select a size and choose 1-3 ice cream flavors. Add as many toppings as you'd like!
  • Ice Cream Sandwiches — $15.99
    1/2 dozen. Delicious and creamy homemade ice cream sandwiches. There are the real deal. Available in vanilla and chocolate.
  • Shamster Shake — $8.26
    Your choice of any flavor of any of our hard ice cream flavors blended with milk.
  • Classic Sundaes — $8.50
    Classic sundae, your choice of ice cream, hot fudge, whipped cream and cherry. We recommend adding a warm brownie!
  • Banana Split — $11.05
    Your choice of hard ice cream flavors served over a banana and topped with hot fudge, whipped, a cherry and any two toppings.
  • Affogato — $8.49
    Hot brewed coffee served over your choice of ice cream and topped with whipped cream and sprinkles.
  • Ice Cream Float — $6.25
    Classic vanilla bean ice cream served over root beer is a house favorite, but feel free to mix and match from our other ice creams and sodas.

Beverages

  • Fountain Beverage — $3.25
  • Bottled Gold Peak Tea — $2.99
  • House-Made Hot Brew Coffee — $3.49
    Piping hot and freshly brewed breakfast blend.
  • Joes' Tea — $2.99
    Peach, lemon, lemonade.
  • Joe’s Iced Tea — $3.00
    Half n half, peach, lemon, raspberry.
  • Jarritos — $2.99
    Mandarin, Lime, Sangria, Tamarind
  • Bottled Water — $2.75
    Mandarin, Lime, Sangria, Tamarind
  • Soda — $2.75
    Diet coke, coke, sprite, root beer.

Specials

  • Croissant a La Mode — $8.49
    Deliciously deep-fried croissant with your choice of handcrafted ice cream, chocolate drizzle and powdered sugar. Regular -2 scoops and Large -3 scoops.
  • Mac n' Cheese a la Kel — $8.49
    Cheesy, creamy, delicious homemade mac n' cheese. This is Petey Wheaty's daughter's recipe, who he calls Kel.

Perfectly Southern

  • Fried Chicken - 4 pcs — $11.99
    Served with one Biscuit
  • Fried Chicken - 12 pcs — $23.99
    Served with three biscuits
  • Fried Chicken - 8 pcs — $18.99
    Served with two biscuits
  • Chicken Tenders - 3 pcs — $10.95
  • Chicken Tenders - 6 pcs — $16.95
  • Chicken Tender - 9pcs — $24.95

Quesadillas

  • Chicken Quesadillas — $11.00
    Guacamole, cheese, beans.
  • Steak Quesadillas — $12.50
    Guacamole, cheese, beans.
  • Shrimp Quesadillas — $13.50
    Guacamole, cheese, beans.
  • Vegetarian Quesadillas — $10.00
    Cheese, portobello mushrooms.
  • Cheese Quesadilla — $9.00
    Cheese.

Tacos

  • Chicken Tacos (3) — $11.00
    Chicken, cheese, pico de gallo.
  • Steak Tacos (3) — $13.00
    Steak, cheese, pico de gallo.
  • Shrimp Tacos (3) — $12.00
    Shrimp, cheese, pico de gallo.
  • Al Pastor Tacos (3) — $11.00
    Pork, cheese, pico de gallo.

Tostadas

  • Chicken Tostada — $6.00
    Chicken, lettuce, tomato, cheese.
  • Regular Tostada — $3.50
    Lettuce, tomato, cheese.
  • Flautas Fried Tortilla (3) — $9.00
    Cheese, sour cream, lettuce, tomato.

Burritos

  • Steak Burrito — $13.00
    Cheese, steak, Mexican rice.
  • Chicken Burrito — $11.00
    Cheese, chicken, Mexican rice.
  • Vegetarian Burrito — $10.00
    Cheese, beans, lettuce, tomato, portobello mushrooms.
  • Al Pastor Burrito — $11.00
    Pork, Mexican rice, pico de gallo.

Handcrafted Ice Cream

  • Cups or Cones — $4.50
  • Shakes — $7.00